Home › Blog › Three firms, three rules
MICROECONOMICSThree firms, three rules
A strawberry stand, a ramen shop and the only ferry to an island. Each one chooses how much to sell and what to charge, and each one follows the same three-step habit to get there. What changes is how much control it has over its price.
A strawberry stand at a farmers' market, a ramen shop on a busy street and the only ferry to a small island don't have much in common. But economists analyse all three with the same toolkit of cost curves, and they answer the same questions about each: how much should it produce, what should it charge, is it making a profit, and will that profit last?
What separates them is the demand side: how much control each firm has over its price. That one difference changes where each firm produces, what it charges, what happens to its profit over time and what a regulator might ask it to do. This post works through all three with the same habit:
1. Find the quantity with a rule. 2. Find the price on the curve buyers are on. 3. Read costs at that same quantity.
Five terms you'll need
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Marginal cost (MC) | The extra cost of producing one more unit. |
| Marginal revenue (MR) | The extra revenue from selling one more unit. |
| Average total cost (ATC) | Total cost divided by quantity: the cost per unit, all costs included. |
| Average variable cost (AVC) | Only the costs that change with output (ingredients, hourly staff), per unit. The gap between ATC and AVC is average fixed cost (AFC): rent, equipment and other costs that don't change with output. |
| Economic profit | Revenue minus all costs, including opportunity costs: what the owner's time and money could have earned in their next-best use. Zero economic profit means the owner earns exactly that normal return, no more and no less. |
Part 1: The strawberry stand
Dozens of growers sell identical flats of strawberries at the market. If one stand asks a dollar more than everyone else, its customers simply walk to the next table. So the stand takes the market price as given. Economists call this a price taker, and a market full of them is perfect competition.
Today the market price is $24 a flat. The stand can sell as many flats as it likes at $24, so its demand curve is a horizontal line at $24. That line is also its marginal revenue: every extra flat sold brings in exactly $24.
The stand's costs are shown in Figure 1. If you like to check with algebra, the curves are MC = 2 + 2Q, AVC = 2 + Q and ATC = 2 + Q + 49/Q, where Q is flats per day. The 49/Q term is the stand's $49 a day of fixed cost spread over its output.
How many flats?
Every firm that wants the most profit keeps producing as long as one more unit adds more to revenue than to cost. It stops where the two are equal: MR = MC. For a price taker MR is the price, so the rule becomes P = MC.
MC reaches $24 at 11 flats. Check it one flat at a time: the 11th flat adds $23 to cost and $24 to revenue, so it's worth selling. A 12th would add $25 to cost and only $24 to revenue, so it isn't.
Don't stop where the price line crosses ATC. That happens twice, at about 2.5 and 19.5 flats (the second is off the right edge of the figure), and both are break-even points, where profit is zero. At 11 flats, profit is as large as it can be.
How much profit?
Read ATC directly above 11 flats, not at the bottom of the bowl. It's about $17.45.
| Economic profit = (P − ATC) × Q = ($24 − $17.45) × 11 ≈ $72 a day |
Because ATC includes opportunity costs, this means the stand covers every cost, including what the grower could have earned doing something else, and still has $72 a day left over.
Using the minimum of ATC ($16) to work out today's profit. The stand isn't producing at the bottom of the bowl today; it's producing 11 flats. Costs must be read at the quantity the firm actually chose.
Why the profit won't last
Seventy-two dollars a day of economic profit is a signal, and other growers can read it. Nothing stops them bringing their own flats next Saturday. As they arrive, market supply shifts right and the market price falls. Our stand's price line slides down with it, and the stand moves down its MC curve to a smaller output.
Entry continues until there is no profit left to attract anyone. That happens when price equals the minimum of ATC: $16, at 7 flats. At that point P = MC = ATC and economic profit is zero. The stand still covers all its costs, including a normal return; it just earns nothing extra. (If the price ever fell below $16, the reverse would happen: some growers would leave until the price climbed back.)
In Profit Painter you run a perfectly competitive firm. Slide the market price and watch the profit rectangle grow and shrink, then let the long run happen and see where entry leaves the firm.
Open Profit Painter →Part 2: The ramen shop
The ramen shop has plenty of rivals, but its broth isn't quite like theirs. If it raises its price a little, it loses some customers but not all of them. That gives it a downward-sloping demand curve. A market like this, with many sellers, products that are similar but not identical, and easy entry, is called monopolistic competition.
A downward-sloping demand curve changes marginal revenue. To sell one more bowl, the shop has to lower its price, and (because it charges everyone the same price) it lowers it on every bowl, not just the extra one. So each extra bowl adds less to revenue than its price. With a straight-line demand curve, the MR line starts at the same point and falls twice as steeply.
The shop's numbers: demand is P = 40 − Q, so MR = 40 − 2Q; MC = 10 + Q; AVC = 10 + 0.5Q; and fixed cost is $100 an hour, so ATC = 10 + 0.5Q + 100/Q.
Quantity first, then price
The rule hasn't changed: MR = MC, which happens at 10 bowls an hour. What has changed is where the price comes from. MR and MC cross at $20, but $20 is not the price. The shop charges the most customers will pay for 10 bowls, which you read straight up on the demand curve: $30.
Reading the price off the MR = MC crossing. That crossing tells you the quantity. For any firm with a downward-sloping demand curve, the price is always read on the demand curve, above that quantity.
Seeing fixed cost on the graph
Fixed cost doesn't have its own curve, but you can still see it. Average total cost is average variable cost plus average fixed cost:
| ATC = AVC + AFC, so AFC = ATC − AVC |
At 10 bowls, ATC is $25 and AVC is $15, so each bowl carries $10 of fixed cost. Multiply by the quantity and you have the grey rectangle: ($25 − $15) × 10 = $100 an hour of fixed cost. The orange rectangle above it, between ATC and the price, is economic profit: ($30 − $25) × 10 = $50 an hour.
Accounting profit vs economic profit
Suppose the $100 of fixed cost is made up of two parts:
- $60 of lease and equipment payments. These are explicit costs: money actually leaves the bank account.
- $40 the owner could have earned per hour as a head chef elsewhere. This is an implicit cost: nothing is paid, but something is given up.
Revenue is $30 × 10 = $300 an hour, and variable cost is $15 × 10 = $150. Her accountant counts only explicit costs; an economist counts both:
| Accounting profit = $300 − $150 − $60 = $90 |
| Economic profit = $300 − $150 − $100 = $50 |
The gap between the two is exactly the implicit cost, $40. Since implicit costs can't be negative, accounting profit is always at least as large as economic profit. That's why a business can look healthy to its accountant while an economist says the owner would be better off doing something else.
The long run: rivals arrive
Fifty dollars an hour of economic profit attracts more noodle shops. Each new one takes a few customers, so our shop's demand curve shifts left. That keeps happening until the demand curve just touches the ATC curve without crossing it. At that point the best the shop can do is break even.
After entry, the shop sells 8 bowls an hour at $26.50, exactly its ATC at that output. Two things stand out:
- Profit is zero, just as in perfect competition. Entry competes it away.
- The shop doesn't produce at the bottom of the bowl. Because its demand curve slopes down, it can only touch ATC on ATC's downward-sloping part, to the left of the minimum. ATC would bottom out at about $24.14 if it served about 14 bowls, but it can't sell that many without cutting its price below cost. Economists call this gap excess capacity. It's part of the price of having a street full of slightly different ramen, which customers value.
What would "efficient" mean?
Society gets the most out of a market when output stops exactly where the value of the last unit to buyers (the price) equals its cost to produce (MC). That rule is P = MC, not MR = MC.
Back in the short run of Figure 2, demand meets MC at 15 bowls and $25. The shop chose 10 bowls at $30, pricing above its marginal cost, so it produces less than the efficient amount. Every firm with a downward-sloping demand curve does this.
Nobody regulates ramen prices in practice, but it's a useful thought experiment: if the shop were made to produce 15 bowls, could it still cover its costs? Read ATC at the new quantity, not the old one: ATC at 15 bowls is 10 + 7.50 + 6.67 ≈ $24.17, below the $25 price. So the shop would still make a small profit, about ($25 − $24.17) × 15 ≈ $12.50 an hour.
In Sourdough Stall you run a small bakery: hire bakers one at a time, watch marginal cost climb as the oven fills up, and find the output where one more loaf stops paying for itself.
Open Sourdough Stall →Part 3: The island ferry
One ferry serves the island. A second operator would need another dock, another crew and another boat, all to carry passengers the first boat could take for almost nothing extra. So the ferry's costs look very different from the other two firms':
- Huge fixed costs: $800 a day for the boat, dock and crew.
- A small, constant marginal cost: $10 for each extra passenger (fuel, ticketing, wear).
Spreading $800 over more and more passengers keeps pulling the average down, so ATC = 10 + 800/Q falls across the whole range of demand. That is a natural monopoly: one firm can serve the whole market more cheaply than two firms splitting it. Demand for crossings is P = 90 − Q, so MR = 90 − 2Q.
Left alone
The ferry company follows the same rule as everyone else: MR = MC, at 40 tickets a day. Then it reads the price up on the demand curve: $50, far above the $10 it costs to carry one more passenger. ATC at 40 tickets is $30, so it earns ($50 − $30) × 40 = $800 a day in economic profit, and because no rival can profitably enter, that profit doesn't get competed away.
The cost to islanders goes beyond the high fare. Some would happily pay more than the $10 it costs to carry them, but less than $50, so they stay home. Those trips would have been worth more than they cost, and they never happen. That lost value is the monopoly's deadweight loss: the shaded triangle, ½ × ($50 − $10) × (80 − 40) = $800 a day.
A regulator steps in
| Pricing rule | Where on the graph | Ferry outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Unregulated: MR = MC | MR meets MC; price read on demand | 40 tickets at $50; profit $800 a day |
| Marginal-cost pricing: P = MC | Demand meets MC | 80 tickets at $10; ATC is $20, so a loss of $800 a day |
| Fair-return pricing: P = ATC | Demand meets ATC (the right-hand crossing) | About 68 tickets at about $21.70; zero economic profit |
P = MC is the efficient answer. Everyone who values a crossing at more than it costs gets one, and the deadweight loss disappears. But because ATC is still falling, marginal cost sits below average cost, so a price equal to MC can't cover the fixed costs. The ferry loses $10 on every ticket, $800 a day in total. Nobody runs a ferry at a loss for long, so marginal-cost pricing only works if someone, usually the government, pays a subsidy to cover it.
P = ATC is the compromise. The ferry covers every cost, including a normal return to its owners, so economic profit is exactly zero and no subsidy is needed. Output is far higher than the monopoly would choose (68 tickets instead of 40) but somewhat below the efficient 80. This is the rule many real utilities are regulated under. Demand crosses ATC twice, at about 12 and about 68 tickets; the regulator picks the right-hand crossing, where more people travel at a lower fare.
The order in the table (efficient output largest, fair-return output in between, monopoly output smallest) depends on ATC still falling where demand crosses it, which is what makes this a natural monopoly. If demand cut through ATC where ATC was already rising, MC would sit above ATC there. The P = MC and P = ATC points would swap places, and P = MC would leave the firm with a profit rather than a loss. Don't memorise the order; read it from the graph in front of you.
Monopoly Regulator puts a natural monopoly in your hands. Switch between letting it maximize profit, the socially optimal price (P = MC) and the fair-return price (P = ATC), and compare price, output and profit.
Open Monopoly Regulator →The through-line
Three very different businesses, one procedure:
| Strawberry stand | Ramen shop | Island ferry | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Market structure | Perfect competition | Monopolistic competition | Natural monopoly |
| Demand it faces | Horizontal at the market price | Slopes down | Slopes down (the whole market) |
| Price vs MC at its chosen output | P = MC | P > MC | P > MC (unless regulated) |
| Long-run economic profit | Zero (entry) | Zero (entry) | Can stay positive (no entry) |
| Long-run output vs min ATC | At min ATC | Left of min ATC (excess capacity) | ATC still falling |
The quantity always comes from a rule: MR = MC for the most profit, P = MC for efficiency, P = ATC for a fair return. The price comes from the curve buyers are on: the price line for a price taker, the demand curve for everyone else. Costs are read at the quantity you chose, never somewhere more convenient. Then the size and sign of the profit rectangle tell you which way the industry will move.
Five questions to test yourself
Work each one out before opening the answer. All of them use the numbers from this post.
01A cheaper Saturday
The strawberry price falls to $20. Using the stand's curves (MC = 2 + 2Q, ATC = 2 + Q + 49/Q), how many flats does it sell, and what is its economic profit?
Answer
Set P = MC: 20 = 2 + 2Q, so Q = 9 flats. ATC at 9 = 2 + 9 + 49/9 ≈ $16.44.
Profit ≈ ($20 − $16.44) × 9 ≈ $32 a day. It's still positive, so growers keep entering and the price keeps falling toward $16.
02Stay open or close?
The price crashes to $10. Should the stand still pick and sell strawberries this week?
Answer
Yes. P = MC gives Q = 4 flats. There, AVC = 2 + 4 = $6, so the $10 price covers variable cost with $4 a flat left over toward fixed costs.
Operating: revenue $40, total cost 2(4) + 4² + 49 = $73, a loss of $33. Closing: the stand still owes its $49 of fixed cost, a loss of $49. Operating loses less. The rule: in the short run, keep producing as long as price covers average variable cost; shut down only if price falls below the minimum of AVC (here, $2).
03Name the rectangle
In Figure 2, which rectangle is economic profit, which is fixed cost, and how big is each?
Answer
Economic profit is the rectangle between ATC ($25) and price ($30), from 0 to 10 bowls: ($30 − $25) × 10 = $50.
Fixed cost is the rectangle between AVC ($15) and ATC ($25): ($25 − $15) × 10 = $100. It's a cost, not profit.
04Why not the bottom of the bowl?
In long-run equilibrium, why doesn't the ramen shop produce at minimum ATC like the strawberry stand does?
Answer
Its demand curve slopes down, so it can only touch ATC where ATC also slopes down, to the left of the minimum. Zero profit arrives at 8 bowls, below the roughly 14 bowls that would minimize ATC. That gap is excess capacity. The strawberry stand's demand is flat, so it touches ATC exactly at the bottom.
05The subsidy bill
If the regulator insists on P = MC for the ferry, why does the ferry need a subsidy, and how much?
Answer
At 80 tickets the fare is $10 but ATC is $20, so the ferry loses $10 a ticket: $800 a day, exactly its fixed cost.
Whenever ATC is falling, MC is below ATC, so a price set equal to MC can never cover average cost. That's why marginal-cost pricing of a natural monopoly always needs a subsidy.
A short checklist for any market-structure graph
- Is the firm's demand horizontal or downward sloping? That tells you whether it's a price taker.
- Quantity from the rule (MR = MC, P = MC or P = ATC); price from the demand curve or the price line, never from the MR = MC crossing.
- ATC and AVC read directly above the chosen quantity.
- Profit = (P − ATC) × Q, and its sign tells you whether firms will enter or leave.
- Fixed cost = (ATC − AVC) × Q.
- If demand crosses ATC twice, the fair-return regulator wants the right-hand crossing.